Remember back in a different political time when Sarah Palin mocked the Obama followers, saying “How’s it going for you, that hopey-changey thing?” How irritating that was and how good it felt to be on the side of hope and change. But how painfully accurate those snarky Palin sentiments feel today. Most of the people in my close circle have stopped following the news, finding it too depressing and alarming. They are taking a break. Eventually they hope to figure out what to do next.
I have a niece who has a job in creating hope and change.
Her job description has always seemed so vague and made-up and some of the
cynical folks amongst us (me included) sort of discounted her job as not being
real.
I stand corrected.
A few months ago, my niece Ella sent a message to her father
Charles, my sister Anna and me, telling us that she had signed us up to
participate in an all-day workshop at Oberlin. This was something about
dialogue. We were meant to represent our various professions, and to talk about
how dialogue is useful in our work. Or that’s what I understood.
I didn’t think about it much, and I couldn’t quite believe
that Ella had the chutzpah to just tell us what we were going to do on a
November weekend. But, because we love Ella and Charles, we ended up going. She
asked and we went. In my case, my whole crew had to prepare for a Saturday
without me. That was not a big ask, but it was definitely an extra effort from
everyone.
We drove straight through on the so-familiar route that the
three of us have taken so many times in our lives – as children of alumni, as
students, as alumni, as parents of students. And now, apparently, as
parents/aunts of an alumna. We slept in Ella’s one bedroom apartment – me and
Anna in a small double bed that was something of a hot dog bun, Charles on an
air mattress, Ella on the couch. Already this story shows how passive we were
about the plan. We let Ella invite us to sleep in her small apartment. We
didn’t even behave like normal adults and stay in a hotel room with two double
beds. We were thinking like Oberlin students, not like grown-ups with jobs.
The workshop was called a Summit. This is the third of these annual events.
There was a keynote speaker, there were break-out sessions, there was good
food, and the setting was professional and lovely. It was held at the recently
built Hotel at Oberlin, which replaced the dumpy and dark Oberlin Inn of our
era. This one has Maya Lin’s name on a plaque, so she had something to do with
it. Everything about the space was perfect for this event – scale,
architecture, lighting, catering.
This was a voluntary workshop and students didn’t get any
credit. They chose to come on a Saturday morning and spend a beautiful day
indoors, listening and engaging in dialogue with adults of various professions from
the outside world.
The content doesn’t really matter, and it’s not all that
interesting. We learned about what Ella has been doing at her alma mater – she
has been hosting a regular series of meetings, feeding people at each gathering
(a huge task, cooking for 45 people three times a week, by herself as far as we
can tell), and facilitating their learning of how to listen and speak in
groups. There are groups that talk about gender issues, or racism, or other
social justice topics. There is something called Inter Group Dialogue and
something closely related called Barefoot Dialogue. Essentially, when you are
in dialogue, you are not trying to convince anyone of anything. You are
listening closely and learning about other people’s perspectives, trying to
understand their experiences and views. There are silences to digest the
information. There is no effort to reach agreement.
It seems like this might not end up with any evidence of
progress, and yet it does change the conversation between people who disagree
with each other, or who come from very different places. We sat at a table for
meals and breaks with the same group of students. Most of them participate in
these dialogues.
One of them is the facilitator for the Israel/Palestine
dialogue. He comes from Pennsylvania, a Jew with a conservative background. He
says at these gatherings they learn how much people care about the well-being
of people in Gaza and Israel. The dialogues are fruitful. I had been wondering why we never heard
anything about Oberlin during this past year of protests and violence on
campuses. Perhaps this is why. Maybe these dialogues have created an
alternative to mindless chanting and unreasonable expectations. Maybe students
and teachers have a place to listen and be heard about so many painful and
important issues. Maybe there is learning that yields understanding, instead of
closing down the school.
When we were presenting in these panel discussions, my
siblings and I found ourselves ending up in some dark places as we talked about
the future of this planet, or about the work of dealing with trauma patients.
But the students were so earnest and attentive, and because of the framework of
the dialogue method, we were all vulnerable, even with strangers. Charles and I
both brought ourselves to tears at different points as we talked about what was
scary and important about how we all make choices. This surprised us, but we
forged on.
These students are so young and so earnest. A high
proportion of them were international students. Many of them were athletes –
their coaches had encouraged them to get up and spend the day doing this. There
was a kid at our table who barely said a word, except for the obligatory
introductions (name, pronouns, area of study, etc.) but when Anna asked him,
“what’s your distance?” he perked right up and talked about his running. It
sounded impressive – Anna told me later that he is running at the speed of four
minute miles for his distances. He seemed like an unlikely person to
participate in Barefoot Dialogue, but he stayed for the whole day.
The three of us left Oberlin feeling better about lots of
things – the school, how it is putting resources into this kind of teaching,
the students, the future. The whole day, there was no mention of the current
political situation. I think it was a given, in that setting, that we are all feeling
panic and distress. But we were there to practice listening with interest and
compassion, and to find ways to better solutions, maybe, eventually.
This is not new, I know, but it was encouraging to be with some
thoughtful people who are still holding hope for change. Go Ella.
